Wednesday, October 03, 2007

Senator Byrd Introduces "Iran" Amendments to the Defense Appropriations Bill

Senator Robert Byrd (D-WV) introduced Amendment No. 3123 and No. 3133 to the Fiscal Year 2008 Defense Appropriations bill. The amendments would prohibit funding provided by the bill to be used for military operations or activities against any other country without explicit Congressional authorization. The text of both amendments is identical and I'm unsure why two identical amendments were submitted. The amendments do provide exceptions for certain activities. Though the amendments employ a non-country-specific approach similar to Senator Byrd's S. Res. 39, the enactment of either amendment could prevent a military confrontation with Iran. Below is the text of Amendments 3123 and 3133.

Sec. 8107. (a) None of the amounts appropriated or otherwise made available by this Act may be obligated or expended for military operations or activities against any other country without the enactment of an Act or the passage of a resolution passed by the Senate and the House of Representatives specifically authorizing such obligation or expenditure.

(b) The prohibition in subsection (a) shall not apply with respect to the following military operations or activities:

(1) Military operations or activities to directly repel an attack against the territory or the Armed Forces of the United States.

(2) Military operations or activities in hot pursuit of hostile forces who are directly engaged in combat operations against the Armed Forces of the United States.

(3) Intelligence collection activities of which Congress has been appropriately notified under applicable law.

(c) Not later than 48 hours after determining to obligate or expend amounts otherwise prohibited from obligation or expenditure under subsection (a) for purposes of a military operation or activity described in subsection (b), the President shall submit to the Committee on Armed Forces and the Committee on Appropriations of the Senate and the Committee on Armed Forces and the Committee on Appropriations of the House of Representatives a report on such determination, including a justification for the determination.

(d) Nothing in this section shall be construed as limiting the authority of the President under Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution of the United States.

Tuesday, October 02, 2007

Senator Clinton Signs Onto Webb Bill

On October 1, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton (D-NY) signed on to Senator Jim Webb's (D-VA) bill, S. 759, barring funding for military action against Iran without approval from Congress. The gesture is seen in large part as a response for her vote to endorse the Kyl-Lieberman amendment to the Fiscal Year 2008 Defense Authorization bill. Senator Clinton was the only Democratic presidential candidate to endorse Kyl-Lieberman amendment and she was pressed on her vote during last week's debate in New Hampshire.

"I continue to support and advocate for a policy of entering into talks with Iran, because robust diplomacy is a prerequisite to achieving our aims," Clinton said in a statement. "I also support strong economic sanctions against Iran, including designating the Iranian Revolutionary Guards as a terrorist organization, to improve our leverage with the Iranian regime."

Senator Clinton still does not seem to understand that sanctions only undermine diplomacy with Iran and designating the Islamic Revolutionarly Guard Corps a terrorist organization will only undermine US security interests.

Senate Completes Work on Defense Authorization Bill

On October 1, the Senate completed action on the Fiscal Year 2008 Defense Authorization bill. The final vote was 92 – 3 in favor. Over 400 amendments were filed to the bill, and the Senate acted on 214 of them. The House and Senate versions of the bill must now be reconciled in conference.

Iran-related amendments, which passed and are included with the bill
Amendment No. 3017: On September 26, 2007, the Senate voted 76-22 to pass a modified version of Amendment No. 3017 introduced by Senators Jon Kyl (R-AZ) and Joseph Lieberman (I-CT). Senators Lieberman and Kyl dropped paragraphs 3 and 4 under Section (b), the Sense of Senate section, in attempts to alleviate concerns that the resolution might be taken as an authorization for the use of force against Iran. Here is the modified Kyl-Lieberman Amendment.

Amendment No. 2024: On July 12, the Senate voted 90 to 5 to pass a modified version of Sen. Sessions (R-AL) amendment No. 2024. The amendment states that it should be the policy of the United States to develop and deploy, as soon as technologically possible, an effective defense against “the threat from Iran,” and that any U.S. missile defense system in Europe should be complementary to any missile defense system fielded by NATO.Click here to view the modified version of the amendment.

Amendment No. 2073: On July 11, the Senate passed the Lieberman (I-CT), McCain, Kly, Graham, Coleman, Collins, Sessions, Levin, Salazar and Craig amendment No. 2073 with a vote of 97-0. The amendment accuses Iran of assisting forces in Iraq that are contributing to the destabilization of Iraq and the murders of Americans, demanding that Iran cease those activities and requiring the Administration to report to Congress concerning Iran's activities there and responses to those activities. Most notably, the changed version closed with the sentence: “Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize or otherwise speak to the use of Armed Forces against Iran.” Here is the modified version.

Iran-related amendments, which were introduced but were not included with the bill
Senator Gordon Smith (R-OR) filed his bill S. 970 as amendment No. 2166 to expand and strengthen sanctions on Iran and countries that deal with Iran. There was never a vote on the amendment. It is unlikely that S. 970 will come up for a vote as a stand alone measure anytime soon given the Congressional schedule. Senator Shelby also has concerns with the bill and it is being held up in the Banking Committee.

Meanwhile, on Tuesday, September 25, the House version of the Iran Counter-Proliferation Act of 2007, H.R. 1400, passed with a vote of 397-16 on suspension of the rules. Four Republicans and 12 Democrats voted against the measure, with 20 Members not voting.

Monday, October 01, 2007

Iranian Parliament Passes Resolution to Name Army and CIA Terrorist Organizations

In a largely symbolic response to the passage of the Kyl-Lieberman amendment on September 26 expressing the Sense of Congress that the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps should named a terrorist organization, 215 members of the Majlis signed a resolution to urging Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's government to designate the CIA and the US army "terrorist organizations." The vote took place at an open session of the 290-member Iranian parliament on September 29.

This is the precise sort of tit-for-tat escalation US Senators were warned of when considering the Kyl-Lieberman amendment to the 2008 Defense Authorization bill.

According an AP article, "The parliament said the Army and the CIA were terrorists because of the atomic bombing of Japan; the use of depleted uranium munitions in the Balkans, Afghanistan and Iraq; support of the killings of Palestinians by Israel; the bombing and killing Iraqi civilians and the torture of imprisoned terror suspects." A statement signed by the 215 members who voted for the resolution reads, "The aggressor U.S. Army and the Central Intelligence Agency are terrorists and also nurture terror."

Like all Parliamentary legislation, the resolution must first be reviewed and ratified by the Guardian Council, the country's constitutional watchdog composed of six clerics an six jurists, before it can become law.

Flurry of Iran Legislation Activity in the House

On September 26, the House Foreign Affairs Committee agreed to seek consideration under Suspension of the Rules for H.CON.RES.203, which condemns the persecution of labor rights advocates in Iran. The bill is sponsored by Rep. Mark Steven Kirk (R-IL) and has 34 co-sponsors.

On September 27, Rep. Steve Israel (D-NY) introduced H.RES.690 and the bill was referred to the House Committee on Foreign Affairs. The resolution expresses the grave concern of the House of Representatives for Iran and Syria's continued and systematic violations of UN Resolutions 1701 and 1559. This bill concerns Syrian and Iranian interference in Lebanon, particularly in supporting Hezbollah, and calls on Hezbollah to release the Israeli soldiers and for all militias in Lebanon to disband. It expresses "its vigorous support for a democratic Lebanon."

House Resolution Introduced on "Human Rights and Democracy in Iran"

On September 25, H.R.3653, sponsored by Rep. Gus M. Bilirakis (R-FL), to hold the current regime in Iran accountable for its human rights record and to support a transition to democracy in Iran, was referred to the House Committee on Foreign Affairs. The bill makes a direct link "between the state of freedom and democracy within Iran and the efforts of the current regime of Iran to acquire nuclear weapons and the long-term success of the global war on terror." Senator Brownback (R-KS) introduced the Senate version of the bill, S. 1534, on May 25, 2007 and it was referred to the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations.

The bill seeks to amend the Iran Freedom and Support Act (Public Law 109-293; 22 U.S.C. 2151 note) "to make the deplorable human rights record of the Government of Iran a top concern and priority of United States foreign policy" and "to keep the deplorable human rights record of Iran a top priority, irrespective of ongoing nuclear issues."

The bill also calls on the President to appoint a special envoy for human rights in Iran within the State Department. It outlines the dutes of the Special Envoy, who "shall coordinate and promote efforts to improve respect for the fundamental human rights of the people of Iran and work with organizations committed to promoting democracy in Iran." Among other responsibilities, the Special Envoy would "serve as point of contact for opposition groups, diaspora groups, and nongovernmental organizations interested in advocating democracy and human rights in Iran."

The bill concludes with a sense of Congress statement "that the commitment to human rights and democracy of a national of Iran who has applied for a visa to enter the United States should be considered when determining the eligibility of such national for the visa."

Three other Representatives have co-sponsored the bill to date:
Rep McCotter, Thaddeus G. [MI-11] - 9/25/2007
Rep Ros-Lehtinen, Ileana [FL-18] - 9/25/2007
Rep Wolf, Frank R. [VA-10] - 9/25/2007

Barbara Slavin on Ahmadinejad's Visit to New York

Barbara Slavin, senior diplomatic reporter for USA Today and a fellow at the U.S. Institute of Peace, published an Op-Ed in The National Interest on Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's visit to New York. She sums up the implications of his trip well:

"As easy as it is to demonize and ridicule him, Ahmadinejad is a member of a collective leadership that will make decisions in the next few months that could improve the prospects for peace in a troubled region or lead to another devastating conflict. While there is still time, Iranians and Americans should make use of every opportunity for dialogue, even if sometimes it seems like a dialogue of the deaf. As one religious leader, Drew Christiansen, told Ahmadinejad in New York, quoting Winston Churchill: 'to jaw jaw is always better than to war war.'"