Showing posts with label US Military Capabilities. Show all posts
Showing posts with label US Military Capabilities. Show all posts

Monday, July 07, 2008

Is Iran Currently an Existential Threat to the United States?

In a new analysis released today comparing the conventional military capabilities of the United States and Iran, experts at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation conclude that the current threat posed by Iran is exaggerated by conflating it with Iran's potential, but far from certain, acquisition of a nuclear weapon in the future.

The side-by-side comparison is available online.

"It is dangerous to allow speculation about what Iran might be able to do in the future to permeate debates about the threat posed by Iran today," said Carah Ong, Iran Policy Analyst at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation. "Conflating future and present threats creates an artificial sense of urgency about what the United States must do to protect itself."

Iran currently presents a number of serious problems for the United States. Iran could attack U.S. forces in Iraq or use its proxies Hamas and Hezbollah to attack Israel. However, by nearly every quantifiable metric, Iran does not presently represent an existential threat to the United States based on its conventional arsenal.

The United States will spend 99 times more on defense than Iran in the upcoming fiscal year. U.S. fighter aircraft outnumber Iranian aircraft 12.4 to 1, and American planes like the F-22 Raptor are far superior to aging Iranian aircraft.

In fact, out of 24 categories included in the comparison, Iran only possesses an advantage over the United States in two: artillery units and patrol and coastal combatant ships. These two advantages, however, would be meaningless in any imaginable conflict scenario.

"A comparison of the United States and Iran's conventional military capabilities demonstrates the overwhelming superiority of the United States," noted John Isaacs, Executive Director at the Center for Arms Control and Non-Proliferation. "People need to spend less time hyperventilating about the rhetoric of two unpopular leaders and more time using realistic assessments to formulate smart policies."

A nuclear weapon in the hands of Iran would be dangerous, and the United States must take steps to prevent this development. However, direct diplomatic engagement with Iran on the nuclear issue, without preconditions, is one method that the Bush administration has yet to try.

As the comparison makes clear, the United States would be engaging from a position of strength. A recent Gallup poll showed that 59 percent of Americans believe it would be a good idea for the President of the United States to meet with the President of Iran.

"Pursuing diplomacy with Iran is not going to be easy, and it will not resolve all of the outstanding issues overnight," concluded Ong. "But it is an approach that is worth trying, particularly given the disastrous consequences that would result from a military confrontation between the United States and Iran."

The side-by-side comparison is available online.

Wednesday, October 24, 2007

Bush Administration Seeks Funds for Bunker Busters

CQ Today reported today, “Buried in the $196.4 billion supplemental war spending proposal that Bush submitted to Congress on Oct. 22 is a request for $88 million to modify B-2 bombers so they can drop a Massive Ordnance Penetrator, or MOP, a conventional bomb still in development that is the most powerful weapon designed to destroy targets deep underground. A White House summary accompanying the supplemental spending proposal said the request for money to modify ­B-2s to carry the bombs came in response to ‘an urgent operational need from theater commanders.’ The summary provided no further details. The White House and the Air Force, in response to queries, did not provide additional clarification.”

According to defense contractors developing the weapon and its delivery system (Boeing Co. and Northrup Grumman, respectively), it is meant for use against the kinds of hard and deeply buried targets found in Iran and North Korea. The article goes on to state concerns expressed by some members of Congress such as Rep. Jim Moran (D-VA) and Rep. Jim McDermott (D-WA) that this funding request could signify preparations for a military strike on Iran.

To put this in perspective, though, the US already has both nuclear and conventional “bunker busting” capability in its vast arsenal, including the B61 Mod 11 "earth-penetrator" that was deployed in the mid-1990s and the Guided Bomb Unit 28 that was used by the US against at least two targets in Dessert Storm, to name two. The US also sold 100 GBU-28 to Israel in April 2005 and transferred in July 2006, the Israeli military has identified Iran and Syria as targets of this “bunker-busting” conventional technology.